| 2007* |
|
2008* |
| TE - Sheldon Loughner |
|
OL - Kelly Knepshield |
| RB - Logan Small |
|
TE - Jake Gabelt |
| WR - Rob James |
|
OL - Kelly Knepshield |
| DB - Quillian Reid |
|
RB - Jairus Marlow |
|
|
DL - John Jackson |
|
|
LB - Anthony Johnson |
|
|
DB - Antoine Barber |
|
|
DB - Quillian Reid |
|
|
|
| 2009* |
|
2010 |
| DL - John Jackson |
|
WR - Sheldon Loughner (1st Tm.) |
| DB - Rob James |
|
QB - Aaron Smetanka (1st) |
| OL - Kelly Knepshield |
|
OL - Taofik Amokomowo (2nd) |
| WR - Sheldon Loughner |
|
OL - Shane Smith (2nd) |
| RET - Zack Mihalko |
|
WR - Tom Quirin (2nd) |
| LB - David Ribero |
|
LB - Armando Fortunato |
|
|
DE - Jeff Graham (Hon. Ment.) |
|
|
DL - John Jackson (HM) |
|
|
LB - Anthony Johnson (HM) |
|
|
LB - Alex Rowan (HM) |
|
|
DB - Bryan Santos (HM) |
|
|
|
| 2011 |
|
2012 |
| WR - Sheldon Loughner (1st) |
|
OL - Darius McGhee (1st) |
| QB - Aaron Smetanka (1st) |
|
DB - Dan Wirkowski (2nd) |
| OL - Taofik Amokomowo (2nd) |
|
WR - Ricky Douglas (HM) |
| OL - Shane Smith (2nd) |
|
LB - Renny LaRue-Holloman (HM) |
| WR - Tom Quirin (2nd) |
|
LB - JoVaughn Johnson (HM) |
| LB - Armando Fortunato (2nd) |
|
RET - Darius Brown (HM) |
| DL - Jeff Graham (HM) |
|
|
| DL - John Jackson (HM) |
|
|
| LB - Anthony Johnson (HM) |
|
|
| LB - Alex Rowan (HM) |
|
|
| DB - Bryan Santos (HM) |
|
|
|
|
|
| 2013 |
|
2014 |
| OL - Darius McGhee (1st) |
|
DB/RET - Darius Brown (1st) |
| LB - Renny LaRue-Holloman (2nd) |
|
OL - Mike Mackowick (2nd) |
| DB - Dan Wirkowski (2nd) |
|
RB - Shavonta Craft (2nd) |
| WR - Matt Duffey (HM) |
|
LB - Nick Revis (2nd) |
| DL - Mitch DePellegrini (HM) |
|
DB - Renny LaRue-Holloman (2nd) |
| RET - Dwayne Brown (HM) |
|
PK - Morgan Porter (2nd) |
|
|
OL - Logan Portes (HM) |
|
|
WR - Duston Lowman (HM) |
|
|
DB - Matt Jenkins (HM) |
|
|
|
| 2015 |
|
2016 |
| RB - Ryan Crawford (2nd) |
|
WR - D.J. Oceant-Kelly (2nd) |
| LB - Renny LaRue-Holloman (2nd) |
|
WR - Damon Black Jr. (2nd) |
| DB - Devin Anderson (2nd) |
|
LB - Matt Jenkins (2nd) |
| OL - Tomas Apodaca (HM) |
|
DB - Devin Anderson (2nd) |
| OL - Reid Brinkhoff (HM) |
|
OL - Reid Brinkhoff (HM) |
| WR - Damon Black Jr. (HM) |
|
RB - Shavonta Craft (HM) |
| DL - Cody Henry (HM) |
|
QB - Derek Stewart (HM) |
| LB - Matt McCarty (HM) |
|
DL - Cody Henry (HM) |
| P - Mark McCracken (HM) |
|
DB - Cameron Mack (HM) |
| PK - Steven Scherer (HM) |
|
|
|
|
|
| 2017 |
|
2018 |
| WR - Damon Black Jr. (2nd) |
|
DL - Cody Henry (2nd) |
| P - Christian Witchey (2nd) |
|
DL - Izaak Gray (2nd) |
| OL - Tyler Rau (HM) |
|
LB - Hauns White (2nd) |
| OL - Reid Brinkhoff (HM) |
|
P - Christian Witchey (2nd) |
| WR - Dalton Deitrich (HM) |
|
OL - Cullen Higgins (HM) |
| RB - Jhanard Dorsett (HM) |
|
OL - Colton Belmont (HM) |
| DL - Izaak Gray (HM) |
|
RB - Mike Stasko (HM) |
| LB - Hauns White (HM) |
|
LB - Mike Turner Jr. (HM) |
| LB - Kim Ornis (HM) |
|
DB - Cameron Mack (HM) |
|
|
RET - Sam Nowicki (HM) |
|
|
|
| 2019 |
|
2020 |
| P - Christian Witchey (1st) |
|
OL - Colton Belmont (1st) |
| OL - Colton Belmont (2nd) |
|
RB - Mike Stasko (2nd) |
| RB - Mike Stasko (2nd) |
|
RB - David Marshall (2nd) |
| OL - Bruce Johnson (HM) |
|
LB - Cam Norris (2nd) |
| DL - Cody Henry (HM) |
|
P - Jared Gonzalez (2nd) |
| DL - Izaak Gray (HM) |
|
OL - Bruce Johnson (HM) |
| LB - Cam Norris (HM) |
|
WR - Keith Kalp (HM) |
|
|
QB - Brady Walker (HM) |
|
|
LB - Jack Poling (HM) |
|
|
DB - Kyle Coombe (HM) |
|
|
|
| 2021 |
|
2022 |
| WR - Molayo Irefin (2nd) |
|
WR/RET - Molayo Irefin (1st) |
| LB - Cam Norris (2nd) |
|
DB - Ahmad Shaw (2nd) |
| OL - Nate Bettwy (HM) |
|
OL - Nate Bettwy (HM) |
| OL - C.J. Ciecierski (HM) |
|
QB - Brady Walker (HM) |
| QB - Brady Walker (HM) |
|
RB - D.J. Gray Jr. (HM) |
| LB - Joanes Polynice (HM) |
|
LB - Joanes Polynice (HM) |
| DB - Jaden Pratt (HM) |
|
LB - Jaden Edmonds (HM) |
| PK - Adam Koscielicki (HM) |
|
DB - Ethan Facey (HM) |
|
|
|
| 2023 |
|
2024 |
| P - Kyle Murray (2nd) |
|
LB- Wiley Purry (HM) |
| LB - Wiley Purry (HM) |
|
RB- Billy Beck (HM) |
| LB - Nathan Sullivan (HM) |
|
K- Adam Koscielicki (HM) |
| DB - Ethan Facey (HM) |
|
P- Daishaun Alexander (HM) |
| DL - Max Pisula (HM) |
|
DB- Robbie Labuda (HM) |
| WR - Kaelib McElroy (HM) |
|
LB- Nathan Parker (HM) |
